Interview with Molly Leach

lengle wrinkle2012 203x300 Interview with Molly Leach

About a month ago I began an email conversation with Molly Leach about her new cover and interior book design for Macmillan’s 50th anniversary edition of Madeleine L’Engle’s A Wrinkle In Time. Have you seen it? The dust jacket is an updated homage to Ellen Raskin’s original, redrawing the circles and the small silhouettes of main characters, updating the type treatment, and opting for warm autumn colors instead of Raskin’s blue and green. But under the dust jacket is the original cover in all its Time Tunnel-ish glory, so memorable to those of us who read Wrinkle back in its early days.

Molly also did the interior design, and as a designer myself I was eager to hear about some of her more subtle choices. Best known for designing Jon Scieszka and Lane Smith’s collaborations in a suitably in-your-face style, she’s also good at plain old everyday design — the kind most people don’t notice unless it’s done badly.

Here’s our conversation, which eventually included Macmillan art director Anne Diebel as well.

Q: What direction did Macmillan give you when they asked you to design the new cover?

Molly Leach: Anne Diebel at Macmillan sent me a PDF of the original cover and asked me to take that as the inspiration. I LOVE Raskin’s cover and was happy to oblige! I decided to keep the mesmerizing Saul Bass look but make it bolder. I hope we ended up doing that. I didn’t really consider anything else; it seemed obvious to me.

wrinkle2012 oldnewjackets 500x377 Interview with Molly Leach

In the new edition, Ellen Raskin’s original cover can be found under the jacket.

Q: What about the interior book design? How did you make those choices?

Molly Leach: I designed the chapter heads based on the cover design, along with the title page. I wanted it to look like it was a cohesive unit. More dizzying circles! More Bold fonts! (more cowbell!) The chapter head font is Bureau Grotesque. But it’s not grotesque at all, just sort of in your face. I didn’t have a copy of the original edition, but I’d guess that nothing special was done, since they didn’t do much decorative stuff like that on the insides in those days. I have actually never read the book. I understand that it was required reading for many, but not for me for whatever reason. I did read a sort of “Cliff’s Notes” synopsis online when I was given the assignment to design this edition.

wrinkle2012 chapteropen 500x368 Interview with Molly Leach

A chapter head for the 2012 edition

The body copy is Garamond Premier Pro which I find to be extremely readable, grown-up and downright pretty. I have a loose leading for more easy reading. You have to think of the age group when selecting point sizes and leading. Generally, the bigger the leading and point size, the younger the audience (except it’s good for very old people too!)

wrinkle garamondsample Interview with Molly Leach

Garamond Premier Pro typeface used in the 2012 edition

wrinkle timessample Interview with Molly Leach

Here is the same text using Times New Roman. Notice how much more elegant Garamond is, in part because it has a distinct personality most noticeable in the letters a, e, and t.

I didn’t actually complete the insides, Jay Colvin did that at Macmillan, but I gave style sheets of a sort. By the way, it’s not easy to make a file with 275 pages. I think sometimes people think you just push a computer button and it takes care of itself. Well, it’s not the case — there are widows and orphans to deal with, a set page count, a set text content, etc. It can become quite the puzzle at times. An enjoyable puzzle, but a puzzle nonetheless.

I didn’t get a chance to tackle the “Cast of Characters” spread. Jay did that as well, and a nice job I must say. Imagine having that handed to you in long form without any graphics at all and trying to make it understandable at a glance. Crazy! I didn’t have the time to complete that, but I really enjoy those challenges.

wrinkle2012 castcharacters 500x381 Interview with Molly Leach

The cast of characters spread was designed in-house.

I think soon all interiors will have four-color insides — not for artwork, necessarily — but for graphics like that Cast of Characters, title pages, and chapter heads. And they will be able to do it for the same price as one-color [black ink]. That would have been nice for this project, but alas, not there yet. I look forward to that!

wrinkle2012 titlepage 500x390 Interview with Molly Leach

Title page design for the 2012 edition

Q: Did you determine the type size and leading or did you just give them a suggestion which they adapted based on chapter length, page count, etc.?

Molly Leach: I suggested 11/16 body copy and they used that size and leading, as far as I know.

Note: “11/16 body copy” means that the type size for the main text was 11 points and the leading — the space between lines — was 16 points.

Q: There’s lots of shiny stuff on covers these days — foils, varnishes, metallic inks. Some covers use these in a gratuitous, over-the-top way, but this cover seems to have the perfect balance of effects. Who made that happen?

Molly Leach: Anne Diebel, the art director, is the person best suited to answer that question. She knew the budget, made suggestions and had some tests run which she shared with me.

She’s very deft at effects! And while I love the final cover, as a general rule, I’m not all that into the over-the-top shiny stuff. This one happens to work very well. It makes the cover really pop and seem even more dizzying.

We sent the question along to Anne Diebel. Here’s what she added.

Anne Diebel: I consulted with Molly Leach about the special effects, of course. As she mentions, she does not usually go in for a lot of glitz, nor do I, but a golden anniversary of a beloved classic like Wrinkle in Time seems to cry out for gilding, if for no other reason than to command attention next to all that’s out on the shelves in 2012.

We proceeded very carefully however, with respect to Molly’s subtle and lovely design. One of our in-house designers, Alex Garkusha, built the complex mechanical in InDesign. The four-color digital art was on one layer and the various special effects and how they were to be applied were specified on further layers. This sort of thing is his specialty. We started with silver metallic paper and printed the four-color art that Molly supplied on top. In some areas we wanted the foil to appear full strength so the Newbery sticker is actually silver foil with CMYK overprinting and embossing — not a sticker at all.

We did not want the whole cover to be screaming with metallic, so Alex composed a white ink layer in the mechanical that rests between the silver metallic and the four-colors with gradations of tone so varying degrees of metallic could show through the CMYK. In that way the background areas have a softly dusted sort of look with variations that match the painted mottling in the art. In the areas where you discern no metallic — the letterforms and the figures — 100% white was applied. Where you see pure metallic shine — in the “sticker” and the thin gold bands — 0% white was applied. Think of the white ink layer as a mask.

Then to subdue the intricate background, we embossed the letterforms and the figures so that they sort of sit above the rest. This upper plane also received spot UV (varnish) while the background is matte. Finally, the thin gold bands moderate slightly so that they sort of come forward in the design and then recede. With all this complication, our particular concern was that it not make you feel dizzy to look at it. Toward that end, we did a press proof with a full variety of options implemented.

wrinkle closeups Interview with Molly Leach

If you look closely, you can see the small dots of ink on top of the silver metallic paper, adjusting the circles and the Newbery medal to make different shades of gold.

Lolly: Thank you, Molly and Anne. It was fun to talk shop and shed light on some of the subtleties of design and production.

Our conversation got pretty technical, so I’d be happy to answer questions and explain any jargon or techniques that need more explanation. Ask in the comments.

share save 171 16 Interview with Molly Leach
Lolly Robinson About Lolly Robinson

Lolly Robinson is the designer and production manager for The Horn Book, Inc. She has degrees in studio art and children's literature and teaches children's literature at Harvard University's Graduate School of Education. She has served on the Caldecott and Boston Globe-Horn Book Award committees and blogs for Calling Caldecott and Lolly's Classroom on this site.

Comments

  1. Another paperback cover design was by PETER SIS in l977 the also contained An Introduction by the Author.

  2. Chris Killingsworth says:

    Thanks for the interesting write up.
    Garamond it is!
    ;-)

Comment Policy:
  1. Be respectful, and do not attack the author or other commenters. Take on the idea, not the messenger.
  2. Don't use obscene, profane, or vulgar language.
  3. Stay on point. Comments that stray from the topic at hand may be deleted.

We are not able to monitor every comment that comes through (though some comments with links to multiple URLs are held for spam-check moderation by the system). If you see something objectionable, please let us know. Once a comment has been flagged, a staff member will investigate.

We accept clean XHTML in comments, but don't overdo it and please limit the number of links submitted in your comment. For more info, see the full Terms of Use.

Trackbacks

  1. […] interview with Molly Leach about the 50th anniversary edition of A Wrinkle in […]

  2. […] Molly Leach discusses the design of the 2012 edition of A Wrinkle in Time […]

  3. […] Smith and Molly Leach are a bookmaking couple from Connecticut. Lane writes and illustrates books, and his wife Molly […]

  4. […] your mind out of the gutter March 21, 2012 By Lolly Robinson 14 Comments While working on my interview with Molly Leach about her jacket and interior design for the 50th anniversary edition of A Wrinkle in Time, I was […]

  5. […] consummate designer Molly Leach, who is also Smith’s wife, designs all of his books. (Check out this great video of the two […]

Speak Your Mind

*