Hard-boiled nursery rhymes, a one-that-got-away big-fish tale, and more. These four folklore-inspired picture books offer humorous shakeups of beloved story types and the characters who inhabit them.
David Levinthal recasts the events of fairyland as crimes (“The Three Bears” is a breaking-and-entering case; “Snow White” is an attempted murder) in Who Pushed Humpty Dumpty?: And Other Notorious Nursery Tale Mysteries. Binky, a laconic and rumpled frog detective, investigates the mayhem, and Levinthal’s fun with scene-of-the-crime details is contagious. John Nickle’s dramatic, hard-edged paintings, with their hint of grotesque misanthropy, fulfill the story’s potential. (4–7 years, Random/Schwartz & Wade)
In Jangles: A Big Fish Story by David Shannon, a father tells his son a one-that-got-away tall tale. Jangles, legendary trout of Big Lake, had “broken so many fishing lines that his huge, crooked jaw was covered with shiny metal lures and rusty old fishhooks.” Working with a palette as dark and evocative as the depths in which his elusive character dwells, Shannon provides formidable close-up views of this battle-scarred, larger-than-life character. (4–7 years, Scholastic/Blue Sky)
The calculating dinos of Mo Willems’s Goldilocks and the Three Dinosaurs plan to lure Goldilocks into their home with chocolate pudding, then swoop in for a snack of “chocolate-filled-little-girl-bonbons.” However, the over-eager (and highly unsubtle) creatures give themselves away, allowing their would-be victim to beat a hasty retreat. The meta elements fly fast and furious throughout this zany tale. (3–5 years, HarperCollins/Balzer + Bray)
Snarky Mr. Wolf puts up a tough front in Debi Gliori’s What’s the Time, Mr. Wolf?, but neither the story’s recognizable nursery-rhyme and fairy-tale characters—nor readers—will buy his big-bad act. As the hours pass, readers will quickly figure out that it’s a special day, leading to the story’s rewarding climax: a surprise birthday party. Watercolor and pen-and-ink illustrations show Mr. Wolf’s mood going from grumpy to grateful. (3–5 years, Walker)
From the November 2012 issue of Notes from the Horn Book.