Horn Book Reminiscences
From Lillian N. Gerhardt
The Horn Book was just ending the celebration
of its first forty years of publication when I went to work for
the advance review agency Kirkus Review Service.
Its founder, Virginia Kirkus, was seventy years
old and still an active presence on the staff. Unlike most who reach
that age, Kirkus was disinclined to reminisce about her years as
one of the first children’s book editors or about the luncheon
coterie of editors who eventually formed the Children’s Book
Council. Direct questions about the people and events of the early
years of departmentalized children’s book publishing got short
shrift. Nevertheless, Kirkus unprodded would occasionally drop a
nugget from those golden days. One time she volunteered a story
about her regard for the Horn Book.
We were lunching at our desks. To my discredit,
I was eating a sloppy deli sandwich using a copy of the Horn
Book as a placemat. Kirkus noticed. She said, “When Harper
Brothers invited me to submit a proposal for setting up a children’s
book department, I made a beeline to the Central Children’s
Room at New York Public Library and studied the contemporary children’s
books, lists, guides, and reviews there for two weeks from opening
to closing time. I read every issue of the Horn Book cover-to-cover
from its first issue.” (It was then six years old.)
Kirkus said the Horn Book was enormously
helpful to her successful proposal, much more so than the newspapers
and other periodicals that gave space to books for children. “It
took children’s books seriously as a literary form and children’s
reading as an important part of a child’s development.”
Kirkus said that the magazine’s articles read like good conversation
with people focused on the provision of quality books for children.
I remember this so clearly not just because any
personal story from Kirkus was rare, but because it is even rarer
for the editors of one book review agency to sit around dwelling
generously on the strengths of another.
Thirty-five years later, the appraisal Virginia
Kirkus made of the Horn Book’s ability to carry out
its enduring mission “to blow the horn for good books”
for children is still demonstrably right on the mark — an
enormous help to those who take work with young readers seriously.
Happy seventy-fifth anniversary. Trumpet on!
| Lillian
N. Gerhardt was, until her recent retirement, Editor-in-Chief
of School Library Journal. |
 |
From the September/October 1999 issue of Horn Book Magazine

More Horn Book reminiscences
|