Subscribe to The Horn Book

>Having It Both Ways

>The recent “Battle of the Books” match-up between Shadow Country and The Disreputable History of Frankie Landau-Banks has caused some debate around the YA blogosphere; see Liz B.’s post and the comments there attached for some enlightening discussion.

I won’t vote since I haven’t read Shadow Country but I like the way the debate bares the fundamental question about the difference between books for youth and books for grownups: is there a difference and what is its nature? To my mind, it’s this question that keeps children’s/YA lit as a genre perking along and it’s only when we have it answered that we’ll find ourselves in trouble. (As far as linking children’s and YA books goes, that’s a question answered by publishing history.)

Here’s a corollary question. What if Frankie had been published as a book for adults? As crisply observed social comedy, the book has definite cachet within its genre, and its nomination for the National Book Award was both deserved and no surprise. But what if it wasn’t YA, simply undifferentiated (category-wise) fiction? I’m guessing it would have lost to Shadow Country without a murmur or reproach. The fact that Frankie is a YA book gains it a certain recognition (both within and without the YA walls) it would never get otherwise.

I’ve been listening to Sissy Spacek’s stunning reading of To Kill a Mockingbird, another book that provokes the what’s-the-diff question, as it is a book published for adults now mostly first-encountered by adolescents. I read it in fourth grade and not since; what’s striking me now is how much I missed being more allied with Scout-the-child-subject than Scout-the-adult-narrator. I remain glad to have read it at nine but it’s very much an adult book.

Let’s leave the question of just how stupid this kind of book tournament is for another time. SLJ is going to be running one this spring and I’ve said I’ll judge a round (just because it’s stupid doesn’t mean it isn’t fun) and will let you know what it’s like.

Roger Sutton About Roger Sutton

Roger Sutton has been the editor in chief of The Horn Book, Inc, since 1996. He was previously editor of The Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books and a children's and young adult librarian. He received his M.A. in library science from the University of Chicago in 1982 and a B.A. from Pitzer College in 1978. Follow him on Twitter: @RogerReads.



  1. >Hmmm… I thought the commentator over at the Rooster’s comparison to Prep was apt — though I’d argue Frankie is the better book, handling larger issues with more nuance. So I’m not convinced it would be published to silence if it had been packaged for adults.

    The Tourney of Books is always interesting, imo, and always good for a kerfluffle or two’s worth of debate. And nice for those of us who don’t care about the other kind of March madness. It’s harmless fun, and the book world — particularly the part of it that involves literary books for adults — can use more of that. (For past year kerfluffle example see commentary on Mark Sarvas’ judging; though he’s been vindicated in this tourney.) I’m glad to see them including a literary book from another part of the spectrum.

  2. Jeannine says:

    >”Just because it’s stupid doesn’t mean it isn’t fun” has to be one of the best lines I’ve ever read.
    Jeannine Atkins

Comment Policy:
  1. Be respectful, and do not attack the author, people mentioned in the article, or other commenters. Take on the idea, not the messenger.
  2. Don't use obscene, profane, or vulgar language.
  3. Stay on point. Comments that stray from the topic at hand may be deleted.

We are not able to monitor every comment that comes through (though some comments with links to multiple URLs are held for spam-check moderation by the system). If you see something objectionable, please let us know. Once a comment has been flagged, a staff member will investigate.

We accept clean XHTML in comments, but don't overdo it and please limit the number of links submitted in your comment. For more info, see the full Terms of Use.

Speak Your Mind