Have Book Bag, Will Travel:
A Practical Guide to Reading Aloud
By Mary M. Burns and Ann A. Flowers
UDDENLY,
LITERACY IS A HOT TOPIC. While definitions may vary, there is general
agreement that it’s a good thing, and the more of it, the
better. The problem seems to be discovering how to nurture it. Because
Americans incline toward Puritanism when faced with self-improvement,
the process can seem singularly dreary. By adding our voices to
the chorus of admonitions and prescriptions, we hope to restore
literacy to its rightful place as a joyous exchange between adults
and children without fear of failure. Basically, we’re promoting
reading aloud, a time-honored tradition. It is educational, but
most of all, it’s fun.
No, we can’t guarantee your child’s
acceptance to the college of his or her choice; nor can we promise
that your listeners will be in the top reading group. But if you
try — and persevere — you will find mutual pleasure
and increased understanding of one another’s ideas and dreams.
You will have opened up a channel of communication that can compete
with for-profit networks. If that happens, reading scores may improve
as well, not to mention achievement in math and science, as a recent
study seems to suggest. But remember, pleasure comes first; story
hour is not simply school in disguise.
Once committed to the idea of immersing your household
in books, how do you begin? Many families have already established
regular story times but want to perfect skills; others may have
found scheduling just a bit too difficult in these hectic days;
still others may have decided that older children are too sophisticated
for get-togethers with books. All of these challenges can be considered
under three major headings: where and when to read; what to read;
how to read.
1. Where and when to read
Just about anywhere and anytime — as long
as you’re not disturbing someone who doesn’t want to
be disturbed. Of course, there’s the familiar bedtime ritual
for toddlers. But have you considered using the time spent waiting
for doctors or dentists? Amusing one child during another’s
music lesson or sports practice? Adding a new dimension to birthday
parties or holiday celebrations with a pre-planned story program?
Bring books to the playground, pool, or shore.
Have books in the car; tapes may be used if motion makes you too
queasy to read. One enterprising mother used to bring books to the
hairdresser! Another brought suitable books to religious services
so that her preschooler wouldn’t fidget during sermons. (They
read aloud before and after the rites concluded.) But you have to
be armed at all times. Remember, paperbacks make it easy to have
a well-stocked traveling library.
2. What to read
You are not alone. Consult your local
children’s librarian. Look for lists, like the one that follows,
which suggest popular titles. Make a file of your own favorites
— the books that make your audiences ask, “Read it again,
please!”
You will find that the right books have certain
elements in common: the themes are clearly defined; plots develop
logically and progressively with few, if any, flashbacks; the characters
are memorable; there is often an element of suspense, perhaps a
problem that must be solved, to keep readers interested. They are
child-centered, but never cute. They offer security, and they frequently
empower the child, particularly preschoolers, without condescending.
Be aware that some books may appeal to older rather than younger
audiences. When looking for new books, compare them with your and
your children’s favorites to see if they measure up. And never
use a book that you yourself don’t enjoy! Remember, shared
pleasure is one of the rewards for reading aloud.
Picture books are prime choices for reading aloud,
particularly in limited spans of time. The stories are short; the
illustrations help to focus the audience’s attention. And
they’re not only for pre-schoolers — just ask the teenagers
and adults who have discovered Lane Smith and Jon Scieszka. We live
in a visual age; the dramatic increase in sophisticated picture
books seems an inevitable development in the electronic era. Many
also appeal to reluctant readers.
Be careful when selecting books with numerous sidebars
or speech-balloons for your initial efforts with larger groups.
These may make it difficult for your audience to follow the storyline.
There are, of course, exceptions that demand some creative interpretation.
Also, be sure that illustrations are sizable enough to be seen at
a distance. Some books, like The Tale of Peter Rabbit in
its original format, are really best suited for sharing with one
or two children. They are for lap-sitters.
And never, never read a book aloud that you haven’t
read first, particularly in a group setting. It may be too long,
too short, boring, inadequately illustrated, poorly synchronized,
or unsuitable for the audience. If a child asks you to use something
unfamiliar, suggest postponing the reading until you have a chance
to preview the selection.
3. How to Read
How to read is closely related to what
to read. Having selected a book you enjoy, read at a pace that allows
your listener(s) to absorb both words and pictures. Developing visual
literacy is an important part of story time. Don’t rush, but
don’t lose the rhythm either. Let the book dictate your tempo.
Although we suggest that you can read just about
anywhere, particularly one-to-one, we also urge you, if possible,
to create a distraction-free environment. Comfortable seating for
both reader and listener(s) is important. And non-glare lighting
is a must; otherwise, those handsome illustrations will be lost
on a squinting audience.
These are just a few basic ideas we’ve learned
as parents, teachers, and librarians. Ann told stories for more
than two decades at the Wayland Public Library; Mary honed her skills
at Playland on Boston Common, near traffic-saturated Tremont Street,
as part of a Boston Public Library outreach program. Believe us,
you can do it!

The stories in the following collection have been
proven successful in holding the interest of children. Some are
suspenseful and exciting, some are funny, some are soothing, but
they all work.
Nursery
Brown, Margaret Wise. Goodnight Moon.
Harper, 32 pp. Illus. by Clement Hurd.
The quintessential bedtime book, quiet, serene, and comforting in
its familiarity.
Carle, Eric. The Very Hungry Caterpillar.
Philomel, 32 pp.
A cutout book in which a caterpillar eats its way through a steadily
increasing number of delectable foods and finally becomes a butterfly
— a natural history lesson and a counting book as an added
bonus.
dePaola, Tomie. Tomie dePaola’s Mother
Goose. Putnam, 127 pp.
Every child needs a Mother Goose; this one contains a wide selection
of nursery rhymes with lively, handsome illustrations and comfortable
large print.
Hest, Amy. In the Rain with Baby Duck.
Illus. by Jill Barton. Candlewick, 24 pp.
Baby Duck does not like the rain, to the consternation
of her parents. But sympathetic Grampa Duck knows just what to do;
he finds her mother’s childhood umbrella and boots. A splendid
book for a rainy day.
Hill, Eric. Where’s Spot? Putnam,
24 pp.
Spot the puppy hides from his mother in a raise-the-flap book that
allows every child to have the pleasure of being Spot’s discoverer.
Wells, Rosemary. Max’s First Word.
Dial, 12 pp.
A board book in which Max quietly outgenerals his bossy older sister
Ruby in her attempts to run his life. Max and Ruby have many epic
confrontations in further sequels. Very gratifying for the not-so-underdog.
Preschool
Freeman, Don. Corduroy. Viking, 32 pp.
It is love at first sight when young Lisa sees Corduroy, a stuffed
bear with one button missing from his overalls, for sale in a department
store, but she lacks enough money to buy him. The happy conclusion
is deeply satisfying.
Hadithi, Mwenye. Hot Hippo. Illus. by
Adrienne Kennaway. Little, 32 pp.
Hippo is so hot! But Ngai, the god of Everything and Everywhere,
allows only fishes to live in the water. So Hippo and Ngai work
out an agreement, and hippos even today follow Ngai’s rules.
Hughes, Shirley. Alfie’s Feet. Lothrop,
32 pp.
Something is wrong with Alfie’s new rain boots; they feel
funny. But the problem turns out not to be Alfie’s boots at
all in a surprise (or maybe not such a surprise) ending.
Keats, Ezra Jack. Peter’s Chair.
Harper, 32 pp.
Peter is certainly not willing to share his own little chair with
his new baby sister, so he takes it and hides. But Mother knows
just what to do.
Sendak, Maurice. Where the Wild Things Are.
Harper, 40 pp.
The most famous picture book of its day retains its fascination
for children, who recognize Max’s bad behavior, his romp with
the wild things, and especially his return home, as part of their
wishes and dreams.
Zion, Gene. Harry the Dirty Dog. Illus.
by Margaret Bloy Graham. Harper, 32 pp.
Harry is a friendly, curious dog whose sooty but enjoyable wanderings
turn his white coat with black spots into a black coat with white
spots. But how will his family ever recognize him now?
Primary
Allard, Harry. Miss Nelson Is Missing! Illus. by James
Marshall. Houghton, 32 pp.
What can have happened to dear Miss Nelson, who deserts her class
in desperation when they keep on acting up? And where did her replacement,
horrible Miss Viola Swamp, emerge from?
dePaola, Tomie. Strega Nona. Simon, 32 pp.
Poor Big Anthony can’t stop Strega Nona’s magic pasta
pot from overflowing in a famous Italian tale.
McCloskey, Robert. Burt Dow, Deep-Water Man. Viking, 64
pp.
Burt Dow’s fantastic adventures out in his fishing dory include
being swallowed and (even more difficult!) unswallowed by a whale.
Rathmann, Peggy. Officer Buckle and Gloria. Putnam, 32
pp.
Officer Buckle, the police safety officer, kind but somewhat dull,
does not realize that his dog Gloria is the real star of his school
talks.
Rayner, Mary. Mr. and Mrs. Pig’s Evening Out. Atheneum,
32 pp.
Mr. and Mrs. Pig carelessly leave their children in charge of Mrs.
Wolf, but the piglets, especially Sorrel, are equal to anything.
Waber, Bernard. Ira Sleeps Over. Houghton, 46 pp.
Feeling ashamed of wanting to bring his teddy bear with him, and
heckled by his sister, Ira is seriously insecure in his first-ever
sleepover, but he finds comfort unexpectedly.
Middle Grades
Cooney, Barbara. Miss Rumphius. Viking, 32 pp.
The tale of Miss Rumphius who, after her retirement as a librarian,
plants lupines all over New England is a beautiful example of a
life well spent.
Mahy, Margaret. The Great White Man-Eating Shark. Illus.
by Jonathan Allen. Dial, 32 pp.
Norvin, a fine but selfish young swimmer who wants to have the whole
beach to himself, finds the perfect way to discourage other swimmers.
Maybe.
Scieszka, Jon. The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid
Tales. Illus. by Lane Smith. Viking, 56 pp.
Folktales as you have never heard them, such as “The Really
Ugly Duckling” and “The Other Frog Prince.” Wild
spoofs and even wilder illustrations will keep you on your toes.
Steig, William. Doctor De Soto. Farrar, 32 pp.
Doctor De Soto, a kindly mouse dentist, treats all animals in pain.
But when a fox tries to take advantage of him, in a menu-planning
sort of way, Doctor De Soto devises a splendid revenge.
Turkle, Brinton. Do Not Open. Dutton, 32 pp.
Miss Moody and her cat, Captain Kidd, find, while beachcombing,
a curious purple glass bottle. Should they open it?
Van Allsburg, Chris. The Stranger. Houghton, 32 pp.
The enigmatic but pleasant stranger recovering at Farmer Bailey’s
house after an accident doesn’t even speak. But unusual weather
and other bizarre occur-rences give rise to questions in the Baileys’
minds.
Mary
Burns and Ann Flowers are long-time reviewers for The Horn
Book Magazine. |
 |
From the March/April 1997
issue of The Horn Book Magazine |