Now you know what we think

So, now you know where the three of us are in September.

I wonder where we will be in January? Now that Lolly, Martha, and I know one another's favorites, we will put our schedule together and start yapping about books soon. Go through our three lists here, here and here if you want a hint as to which books we are likely to discuss in the coming months. There will be many more, of course, as new books are published right through November and December; these will all be considered by the real committee, and we don't want to miss a thing. We are going to do our best NOT to talk about books until you can actually find them in bookstores. (Speaking of bookstores — if you are lucky enough to have a local one, get your tush to that store and buy some of these titles! Your library will have a lot of them, but October and November books are going to be tough to find there.)

We have combed the comments so far and will discuss some of the books you guys have suggested, though we will never be able to discuss all of them. So, take a day or two to keep the suggestions coming! It's especially helpful if you add a sentence or two to explain why you think a particular title should end up with a shiny sticker in January.

Besides talking about individual titles, we will also be discussing issues we see in the picture book world. Is there an issue or concern stuck in your craw that you want us to tackle? Make that suggestion in the comments as well. We do like to talk about Serious Picture Book Issues, but we don't always know what issues concern you most.

So make suggestions, and we will shuffle our papers, toss the dice, and get chatting about Caldecott possibilities.

And just to add an air of panic to my fear of missing something, here is a list from HuffPo. There are titles I haven't even heard of!

 
Robin Smith
Robin Smith
Robin Smith is a second-grade teacher at the Ensworth School in Nashville, Tennessee. She is a reviewer for Kirkus and The Horn Book Magazine and has served on multiple award committees.
Comment Policy:
  • Be respectful, and do not attack the author, people mentioned in the article, or other commenters. Take on the idea, not the messenger.
  • Don't use obscene, profane, or vulgar language.
  • Stay on point. Comments that stray from the topic at hand may be deleted.
  • Comments may be republished in print, online, or other forms of media.
  • If you see something objectionable, please let us know. Once a comment has been flagged, a staff member will investigate.


Sam Juliano

I finally got my copy of Marla Frazee's THE FARMER AND THE CLOWN early today at Manhattan's Book of Wonders. Now I see why Roger raved and others here were so effusive in their praise. I agree with you all lock, stock and barrel. This is an extraordinarily beautiful book, perfect color coordination, with some stunning spreads, and in the end deeply emotional. You have to think that with the two previous Caldecott Honors and the committee's respect for wordless books of high quality that Ms. Frazee is a serious favorite at this point. It is now one of my absolute favorite books of the year. :)

Posted : Sep 22, 2014 05:09


Roger Sutton

Does anyone know what the Caldecott regs are around pop-ups and other movable aspects of a book? Considered, irrelevant, out-of-bounds, no-go?

Posted : Sep 16, 2014 08:33

Robin Smith

I think they are considered as there are a few books with gatefolds which have been honored. And a gatefold is just a sedate pop up.

Posted : Sep 16, 2014 08:33

BarbOutsideBoston

hmmmm...... I feel if they were considered seriously, Robert Sabuda would have gotten some love. However, I may not be able to be objective about his books since I love them so stinkin' much!

Posted : Sep 16, 2014 08:33


Sam Juliano

One more comment here Robin. To address your query about possible "Serious Picture Book" issues, I thought I'd mention here that the vital issue of bullying in our schools will vigorously be addressed this coming Monday in a presentation at my Fairview school by author Bethany Hegedus and illustrator Evan Turk, who will be utilizing slide shows, role-playing and other tie-ins to go with their new Caldecott contender GRANDFATHER GANDHI. After recommending them to our school superintendent, I must say I was thrilled that our local Board of Education gave this event the go-ahead. The matter of bullying is one of the most important today, and it integral to the philosophical fabric of GRANDFATHER GANDHI. I'm sure this will be quite a presentation, and I'll be taking my own notes. :) Though I mainly teach reading to first-graders I will be at this Grade 4 to 8 event, after reading the book individually to all the classes on the previous Friday.

Posted : Sep 16, 2014 07:03


Sam Juliano

Robin, I think 2014 is interesting too in that two of last year's major Caldecott contenders - Aaron Becker and Peter Brown came back with books that are again among the year's most notable achievements - Mr. Becker with his magnificent second book in his trilogy - QUEST (following the Caldecott Honor winning JOURNEY and Mr. Brown with a second subversive treasure to come on the heels of MR. TIGER - MY TEACHER IS A MONSTER. No fall off in quality at all. :) I recently discovered Lizi Boyd's new book too - and it is a worthy follow-up to last year's INSIDE OUTSIDE. The year is heating up!

Posted : Sep 16, 2014 04:53


jules

I meant F&Gs for *next* year -- that's a stack of early 2015 F&Gs I haven't read yet. So, that book doesn't even come out till next year. Carry on! (I'll keep thinking on this.)

Posted : Sep 16, 2014 12:58

Robin Smith

I am jealous of the phrase "stack of F&Gs." Keep on thinking about this. Your encyclopedic brain is a marvel.

Posted : Sep 16, 2014 12:58


View More Comments

RELATED 

ALREADY A SUBSCRIBER?

We are currently offering this content for free. Sign up now to activate your personal profile, where you can save articles for future viewing.

ALREADY A SUBSCRIBER?