2018 School Spending Survey Report
I'm rubber and you're glue
Over on the Horn Book's Facebook page, there's an opinion that Javaka Steptoe only won the Caldecott Medal because his father was John Steptoe.
Over on the Horn Book's Facebook page, there's an opinion that Javaka Steptoe only won the Caldecott Medal because his father was John Steptoe. When pressed for evidence, the (former, as she'll tell you) subscriber replied that "the pattern of ALA award committees in the past several years in its selections of winners/honors. Promote diversity for diversity's sake."Never mind that you've shifted from arguing nepotism to arguing special pleading, we get it, Steptoe only won the Caldecott because he is black. (I wonder what this writer would make of Steptoe's off-the-cuff remark during his acceptance speech that many of the silver-stickered picture books created by African Americans in the past should rightfully be regarded as winners of the gold.) Given that none of us who were not committee members has any evidence to suggest that the committee did anything other than to fulfill its charge to select the most distinguished picture book of the year, I must say that you are full of hot air. And racism: do you not see that assuming someone only won something because of his race says more about your own beliefs than it does about the award?
Added To Cart
RELATED
RECOMMENDED
Please register with us to continue reading.
ALREADY A SUBSCRIBER? LOG IN
We are currently offering this content for free. Sign up now to activate your personal profile, where you can save articles for future viewing.
ALREADY A SUBSCRIBER? LOG IN
Thank you for visiting.
We’ve noticed you are using a private browser. To continue, please log in or create an account.
Add Comment :-
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!
Roger Sutton
I'm not sure what you mean by "the illustrator in the duo." The Dillons were true collaborators in their illustrating. When asked who did what for a particular picture or book, they would exchange puzzled glances and say they had no idea.Posted : Jul 13, 2017 02:43
Sam Juliano
I return here just to clarify the assertion I made in my comments above of a few days ago, since it has been brought to my attention. I did not count the two record-making consecutive Caldecott Medals won by Leo and Diane Dillon as African American wins, as the illustrator in the duo, Diane, is Caucasian. But a husband and wife collaboration for many reasons does complicate things. I know the New York Times obituary credit Leo with being part of the Caldecott equation in those 1969 and 1970 triumphs.Posted : Jul 13, 2017 02:37
Sam Juliano
Let's see. The Caldecott Medal began in 1937. There have been TWO, count em, TWO African Americans who have won the gold. Steptoe and before him Jerry Pinkney for "The Lion and the Mouse." If diversity is such a mitigating concern, why the previous blanks over so many years? The argument is a pathetic one, but beyond it has not factual validity.Posted : Jul 11, 2017 06:58
Roger Sutton
Agnes has a good point. When I evinced dismay with the Caldecott committee's passing over THE FARMER AND THE CLOWN, I was implicitly accusing the committee of indulging in criteria unmentioned in the rules. So yes, I believe that award committees don't necessarily follow their own rules. (But by the way I had nothing to do with BGHB choosing Frazee's book, much as I applauded the choice.) The reason I am accusing you of racism is that you have given no other reason than race for this year's Caldecott choice. You have not stated its deficiencies nor the superior virtues of another candidate. You are doing precisely what you accuse the committee of: making it all about race.Posted : Jul 04, 2017 03:12
Agnes
Not only do you not know my ethnic background, but you blindly assume I am a racist. How shameful. I have literally hundreds of picture books, junior novels and YA boks in my personal library written and/or illustrated by black artists because of their high quality. I faithfully supported the Horn Book for many many years through subscriptions and promoted it to colleagues as the best of the best in children's review sources. We met, Roger, at ALA Annual Conference in 2007 and I was absolutely thrilled to meet the editor of my beloved magazine. My point is, a political agenda is driving the awards; you were upset that The Farmer and the Clown did not garner any attention (as was I), and thus named it winner in the picture book category for the BGHB awards. And, the CSK and Belpre awards are inherently racist: They exclude artists based on the color of their skin. If you want to go the juvenile route, I will conclude with this: You are rubber, I am glue- the truth sticks to me and bounces off of you. PS. YOu may thank me anytime for garnering traffic on this FB page (not much before) and receiving two new subscriptions from K.T.Posted : Jul 03, 2017 07:33