Return to Sender
by Vera Brosgol; illus. by the author
Intermediate    Roaring Brook    320 pp.
5/25    9781250292186    $18.99
e-book ed.  9781250292179    $11.99

Brosgol (most recently Plain Jane and the Mermaid, rev. 5/24) pivots from graphic novels and picture books to an illustrated middle-grade novel (finished art unseen). After the death of his father, ten-year-old Oliver and his mother have “moved on, and on, and on, exploring the corners of his mom’s address book,” relying on the kindness of relatives for places to live. When his eccentric great-aunt Barb dies, leaving her small New York City apartment to Oliver’s mother, Oliver wonders how long it will be until they have to move again. It’s a creepy place: butterflies pinned to the walls, dead caterpillars in the oven, a taxidermied cat perched on a stool, and a neighbor (named Elizabeth Appleblood) who considers Oliver “a perfectly edible child.” Odder still is a mail slot in the living room wall that leads nowhere. When Oliver discovers that it grants wishes, the novel’s “be careful what you wish for” theme kicks in. First, a free pizza is delivered. Expensive sneakers help him fit in better at his new ultra-wealthy private school (where his mother works as a custodian). But the wishes have unforeseen repercussions, and Oliver and his new friend, Colette, must navigate the school as outsiders and face the consequences of their actions. Readers with a taste for absurdity and social satire will relish this imaginative tale.

From the July/August 2025 issue of The Horn Book Magazine.