In To See an Owl, Matthew Cordell takes readers on a quiet journey into darkness, inviting them to seek magic alongside a child. The minimal text features phrases like “If you are very quiet...” and “Wait,” which emphasize emotional depth through anticipation rather than action. Cordell's illustrations, with their deep washes of indigo, charcoal, and silver, reveal the owl's warmer tones, creating a rewarding moment. 

While the book's subtle approach may seem muted amid bold visuals, it raises the question of whether a whisper can compete with a roar. Ultimately, Cordell’s calm rhythms and visual elegance present a unique experience that deserves recognition. 

This book marks a turning point in Cordell’s artistic voice. Unlike his 2018 Caldecott winner, Wolf in the Snow, which focuses on motion and tension, To See an Owl emphasizes patient observation and slow revelations. This tonal shift reflects maturity and range, inviting readers to slow down and appreciate the hidden magic of silence. 

I urge the Committee to view To See an Owl not just as a quiet contender but as a book with profound emotional resonance — one that highlights the power of patience in storytelling. It may be one of the most quietly ambitious picture books of the year. 

[Read The Horn Book Magazine review of To See an Owl]